k-5banner

Feedback | K-5 GeoSource Home | Site Map

k-5banner
 

 

Printer Friendly Version

Investigation Question 1:
In what ways are soil and sand similar and how are they different?

Preparation

|

What to do

|

Assessment

Assessment

Applying Students' Understanding

Ask the students to help you summarize how soil is like sand and how soil is different from sand. Older students might be given this as a writing prompt. Using information recorded on a graphic organizer or Venn diagram as a tools in forming a paragraph is an excellent skill-building activity.

You might want to return to the initial photos and the point made about plants growing more abundantly in soil than in sand. Although Activity 5 will return to this contrast, you might want to initiate a plant growth investigation in the two media. Initially, seeds such as bean seeds will germinate perfectly well in either moist medium. It will take at least two weeks of growth before features of the maturing plants will show soil to be the more favorable medium, all other factors being equal.

You might take one more look at the Venn diagram and say, “So…it seems that some of the particles in soil are like those we found in sand. But I see that soil has many other things as well. What other things does it have in it?” This question prompts students to see that soil is actually a mixture of several media. Tell students that in the next activity, they will devise and use ways to separate this mixture in order to describe its composition.

Back To Top

Revisiting Investigation Question 1

Complete this investigation by asking your students to reflect on this question and how their answers may have changed as a result of this investigation. Sand is a collection of particles which are roughly similar. Realizing that soil is different because it is a mixture of many materials and particles will help your students begin to understand its organic nature.

Back To Top

Digging Deeper

There are many kinds of soil. A group of soil scientists from the U.S. made up a way of grouping soils that is used around the world. This grouping has hundreds of named soil types! All soils, however, are made of just a few main things. Soil consists of fine particles of minerals and rocks, decaying plants, and living plants and animals. You can easily see the larger plants and animals. There are even more tiny plants and animals that you can only see with a microscope.

Back To Top

 

Investigation Home

National Standards

Weather

Rocks

At Utah's Vermillion Cliffs a siltstone butte of the Carmel Formation erodes and forms unusual shapes. © Michael Collier Image courtesy of the Earth Science World Image Bank, photo ID: ixvt1a

Send all comments about this website to education@agiweb.org

Last updated:July 23, 2008


This project is supported by the AGI Foundation. Opinions expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the Foundation.

  Information Services |Geoscience Education |Public Policy |Environmental
Geoscience
 |
Publications |Workforce |AGI Events


agi logo

© 2008 All rights reserved. American Geological Institute, 4220 King Street, Alexandria, VA 22302-1502.
Please send any comments or problems with this site to: webmaster@agiweb.org.
Privacy Policy